Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Mary Macken-Horarik's avatar

Yes but it was so much more than 'reading the room' in that story. The writing was bringing into relation the different voices and sensibilities available in a poetry lesson - the poem, several individual students, teacher and mentor with what she knew about language. It was so much richer than 'a room'. But anyway Steve, thanks for the response and the opportunity to think more about the kind of reading a teacher must do (especially as she asks students to engage with something a bit hard like an Auden poem).

Expand full comment
Mary Macken-Horarik's avatar

Hi Steve,

I haven't been able to read all of the pieces you have posted but I am moved by your synthesis of thinking, feeling and ... what is the right verb here .... sensing perhaps that undergirds teaching. The wealth of material, which is all different but revealing of common threads, would make a fantastic multimodal resource for pre-service teachers as they reflect on what has beckoned them into teaching. I am reminded of what another great teacher - Parker J Palmer - taught me through his publications: that we need to bring soul into role. This made all the expressiveness, randomness and hard work in my teaching (the whole kit and caboodle that made up my teaching) feel OK. In recent years, I have found inspiration in Winnicott's idea of the 'good enough mother' and applied it to teaching. What you offer in your vignettes as well as in the larger narratives like Harriet's is very good indeed.

Warmest of wishes.

Mary

Expand full comment
4 more comments...

No posts